Jeff – 88

If you can find it, pick this one. A great Smooth peaty whisky. Everything you look for in an island whisky. Will be very collectable in the future.

Glen – 84

I only wish this was readily available since it just so good. The finish in this one is very nice.

Nose: Iodine, peat, smells like an Islay without the smoke
Body: Light
Finish: Very dry, peat, smoke, some sweetness

Incredibly smooth. An excellent whisky from the Isle of Mull

Brett –81

A Highland from the island of Mull, this is a rather simple dram, with a very fresh nose: lightly briny, with wisps of smoke weaving in & out of the vanilla and oak. An exceptionally light body is followed quickly by a short finish of iodine and muskmelon. An aperitif whisky, for those so inclined.

Glen – 76

A very straightforward Ledaig that left me flat. This dram just didn’t get the blood pumping and came off thin and lacked complexity. No peat in the nose and only a whiff of smoke. Reminded me of the line that Bugs Bunny used to say at the close of each cartoon “that’s all folks”. 

Nose: Grassy, fresh, light brine, a whiff of smoke
Body: Light, thin
Finish: Short, some iodine and brine, very light

lacks complexity.